Cigar List Top Rated Paul's top rated cigars are some you won't want to miss out on. Choose from our highest cigars to get the best experience. Mellow Experience a full bodied taste with a smoother finish with our mellow flavored cigars. Medium Our medium cigars have a more delicate flavor compared to the full and top rated cigars. Full Choose from our wide range of full flavor cigars, that acquire your average amount of tar and nicotine.